Cubic Zirconia vs. Moissanite: Which Shines Brighter?

ALL CHAINS PENDANTS BRACELETS WATCHES RINGS EARRINGS GLASSES CUSTOM

Products

All product

Browse and filter all products in our Ice Treasure store.

Chains

Chains made of metal, silver, and gold, adorned with diamonds.

Pendants

Pendants crafted from metal, silver, and gold, adorned with diamonds.

Bracelets

Handmade bracelets in various widths and designs.

Watches

Ice Trasure signature watch collection.

Rings

Handmade rings in various styles for men and women.

Earrings

Handmade earrings in diverse styles for men and women.

Glasses

Stylish eyewear glasses and sunglasses for both genders.

Custom

Get a quote for a custom piece - as unique as you!

Education

Moissanite

Browse and filter all products in our Ice Treasure store.

Chains

Chains made of metal, silver, and gold, adorned with diamonds.

Pendants

Pendants crafted from metal, silver, and gold, adorned with diamonds.

Bracelets

Handmade bracelets in various widths and designs.

Watches

Ice Trasure signature watch collection.

Rings

Handmade rings in various styles for men and women.

Earrings

Handmade earrings in diverse styles for men and women.

Glasses

Stylish eyewear glasses and sunglasses for both genders.

Custom Design

Account Cart

1. Understanding the Basics: Chemical Composition and Origins

Moissanite: A Rare Find

Moissanite, named after Nobel Prize-winning chemist Dr. Henri Moissan who discovered it in 1893 in Arizona, is an exceptionally rare mineral found in upper mantle rock and meteorites. Although natural moissanite is rarer than diamonds, the term “moissanite” commonly refers to the synthetic version of the stone. The first gem-quality moissanite was introduced to the market by Charles Eric Hunter, founder of Charles & Colvard Ltd. This company patented moissanite in the U.S., producing it under extreme pressure conditions, sometimes incorporating elements like boron, nitrogen, and sulfur. Moissanite is composed of silicon carbide (SiC), featuring a carbon atom surrounded by four silicon atoms in a tetrahedral arrangement. This composition gives moissanite a hardness of 9.25 on the Mohs scale, making it exceptionally durable and resistant to scratches.

Cubic Zirconia: Synthetic Brilliance

Cubic zirconia, often abbreviated as "CZ," was first identified in its natural form in 1937 by German mineralogists M.V. Stackelberg and K. Chudoba, who found it as an inclusion in natural zircon crystals. However, it wasn’t until the 1970s in Russia that synthetic cubic zirconia was developed, initially intended for use in laser technology. Recognized for its brilliant resemblance to diamonds, cubic zirconia quickly became a popular choice in jewelry due to its affordability and diamond-like appearance. Cubic zirconia is the cubic crystalline form of zirconium dioxide (ZrO2). It is created through a process that involves melting zirconium oxide powder with stabilizers like magnesium and calcium at high temperatures of around 4,982ºF. Over several hours, these elements form cubic zirconia crystals, which are then cut and polished for use in jewelry.

2. Optical Properties: Refractive Index and Brilliance

Moissanite: Superior Sparkle

Moissanite stands out with its refractive index of 2.65 to 2.69, which, combined with its adamantine to metallic luster, makes it one of the most brilliant gemstones available—more brilliant than both diamonds and cubic zirconia. Known as the world’s most brilliant gemstone, moissanite’s incredible sparkle is unmatched. Moreover, moissanite exhibits highly dispersive double refractivity (fire), a phenomenon that can be observed when viewing a faceted moissanite under a microscope or jeweler’s loop. This double refraction, where facet junctions appear doubled, is a signature characteristic of moissanite.

Cubic Zirconia: A Shining Star

Cubic zirconia boasts a refractive index of 2.15–2.18, a measure of its ability to bend light. With a vitreous (glassy) luster, cubic zirconia displays a high dispersion rate of 0.058 to 0.066. Dispersion refers to the phenomenon of white light separating into its spectral colors as it passes through the gemstone, creating a captivating fire that surpasses even that of diamonds, resulting in a distinctive rainbow effect.

3. Durability and Hardness: Which Stone Lasts Longer?

Moissanite: Built to Endure

When it comes to durability, moissanite outshines cubic zirconia. With a hardness rating of 9.25, moissanite is more durable and scratch-resistant than cubic zirconia, which has a hardness of 8.25-8.50. This makes moissanite a more practical choice for engagement rings, wedding bands, and other long-term wear jewelry. Moissanite’s superior hardness means it’s less likely to show signs of wear, such as scratches or abrasions, even after years of daily use.

Cubic Zirconia: Durable but Delicate

Cubic zirconia's hardness makes it relatively durable compared to many other gemstones, making it suitable for various jewelry applications. However, despite its hardness, cubic zirconia is prone to abrasion, particularly at the facet junctions, where wear and tear can cause visible damage over time, diminishing its sparkle. The stone is also susceptible to scratches from daily activities. To preserve its appearance, it’s advisable to remove cubic zirconia jewelry during tasks like household cleaning, working out, or lifting heavy objects.

4. Appearance and Style Options

Versatility of Moissanite and Cubic Zirconia

Both moissanite and cubic zirconia are available in a variety of shapes, making them versatile choices for center stones or side stones in various jewelry designs. They can be found in faceted round brilliant, marquise, radiant, princess, emerald, cushion, oval, trillion/triangular/trapezoid, and baguette cuts. This versatility allows them to be used in a wide range of jewelry styles, from classic engagement rings to modern fashion pieces.

Unique Characteristics

Moissanite is typically clear and colorless, though it may exhibit a slight yellow to green tint in larger carat stones. Some moissanite stones also display blue or green undertones, with colorful flashes when reflecting light. Cubic zirconia is known for its colorless appearance, closely resembling diamonds. However, it is also available in a wide range of colors, including pink, blue, green, yellow, and even bi-colored or parti-colored versions, making it an incredibly versatile stone.

5. Price and Value: What Are You Paying For?

Moissanite: A Valuable Investment

Moissanite is more costly than cubic zirconia, reflecting its superior qualities. It is often set in premium metals and may come with certifications or appraisals, depending on where it is purchased. This is important for insurance or resale purposes, as moissanite jewelry does have some resale value, making it a worthy investment, especially for keepsake pieces that can be cherished for generations.

Cubic Zirconia: Budget-Friendly Glamour

Cubic zirconia, on the other hand, is significantly less expensive and is often seen as a higher-quality diamond simulant. Its affordability allows for the creation of large and bold jewelry designs without the hefty price tag of diamonds or moissanite. This makes cubic zirconia a popular choice for those looking for a luxurious look on a budget.

6. Environmental Impact and Ethical Considerations

Moissanite: An Eco-Conscious Choice

Since its introduction by Charles & Colvard, moissanite has gained popularity among those seeking a sustainable, ethical, and socially responsible alternative to natural diamonds. The production process for moissanite generally has a lower environmental impact compared to diamond mining, which involves significant disruption of ecosystems.

Cubic Zirconia: Sustainable Yet Energy-Intensive

Cubic zirconia, while also synthetic and less harmful than mining, involves energy-intensive processes that are being improved with more sustainable practices in newer production facilities. However, its environmental impact is generally considered lower than that of natural diamond mining.

7. Comparative Analysis: Moissanite vs. Cubic Zirconia

Thermal Conductivity

One of the notable differences between cubic zirconia and moissanite that isn’t commonly discussed is their thermal conductivity. Moissanite has a higher thermal conductivity than cubic zirconia, making it similar to diamonds in this respect. This property is often used in gemstone testers to differentiate moissanite from cubic zirconia and other diamond simulants.

Cultural Perceptions and Evolving Trends

The cultural perception of cubic zirconia and moissanite has evolved over the years. In the past, cubic zirconia was often seen purely as a "cheap" alternative to diamonds, but today it’s appreciated for its versatility in fashion-forward jewelry. Moissanite, on the other hand, has gained a reputation for being a conscious consumer choice, valued not just for its brilliance, but also for its ethical implications.

8. Conclusion: Which Gemstone Should You Choose?

When comparing moissanite to cubic zirconia, it’s clear that moissanite offers more in terms of resale value, durability, and overall quality. Moissanite jewelry is a worthy investment, perfect for keepsake pieces that can be cherished for generations. Although cubic zirconia lacks the long-term value of moissanite, it remains a chic and stylish option for those looking for budget-friendly, fashionable jewelry. Ultimately, the choice between moissanite and cubic zirconia comes down to your personal preferences and what you value most in your jewelry. Whether you choose the sparkling brilliance of moissanite or the versatile allure of cubic zirconia, both stones provide beautiful and practical alternatives to natural diamonds.

Janar Kirn

Janar Kirn, from Tallinn, Estonia, is a distinguished entrepreneur and a co-founder of Ice Treasure. With a career spanning since 2017, Janar has made significant strides in the jewelry industry, founding his first brand from the ground up.

Over the years, he has amassed extensive knowledge in the field, becoming a respected educator and jewelry specialist in Scandinavia. Known for his deep passion and expertise, Janar is dedicated to sharing his insights and experiences with others through this platform.

Experience the quality of ICE TREASURE, where our custom and stock jewelry, including chains, bracelets, grillz, watches, rings, earrings, pendants, and glasses, all embody superior craftsmanship and quality, passing the diamond test to ensure your satisfaction.

Quick links

Company

Account