Moissanite vs. Simulated Diamond: Comparison

Products

All product

Browse and filter all products in our Ice Treasure store.

Chains

Chains made of metal, silver, and gold, adorned with diamonds.

Pendants

Pendants crafted from metal, silver, and gold, adorned with diamonds.

Bracelets

Handmade bracelets in various widths and designs.

Watches

Ice Trasure signature watch collection.

Rings

Handmade rings in various styles for men and women.

Earrings

Handmade earrings in diverse styles for men and women.

Glasses

Stylish eyewear glasses and sunglasses for both genders.

Custom

Get a quote for a custom piece - as unique as you!

Education

Moissanite

Browse and filter all products in our Ice Treasure store.

Chains

Chains made of metal, silver, and gold, adorned with diamonds.

Pendants

Pendants crafted from metal, silver, and gold, adorned with diamonds.

Bracelets

Handmade bracelets in various widths and designs.

Watches

Ice Trasure signature watch collection.

Rings

Handmade rings in various styles for men and women.

Earrings

Handmade earrings in diverse styles for men and women.

Glasses

Stylish eyewear glasses and sunglasses for both genders.

Custom Design

Moissanite vs. Simulated Diamond: Comparison

Sep 03, 2024, Update: Sep 03, 2024, Janar Kirn / IceTreasure.com

Favorites

Back

Facebook

Twitter

Messenger

Linked In

Copy link

https://icetreasure.com/blogs/resources/moissanite-vs-simulated-diamond-comparison

"Did you know there are several alternatives to natural diamonds that closely resemble them? A diamond simulant is a stone designed to mimic the appearance of a diamond, though it differs in many physical and chemical properties. Moissanite, although often compared to diamond simulants, stands out due to its unique qualities. Unlike typical diamond simulants, moissanite is a high-quality synthetic version of a naturally occurring mineral and is distinctly different in its physical, chemical, and optical properties.

This detailed comparison between moissanite and simulated diamonds will guide you through the pros and cons of each option, helping you make an informed choice when purchasing jewelry."

1. What Is Moissanite?

Understanding Moissanite

Moissanite was discovered by Nobel Prize-winning chemist Dr. Henri Moissan in 1893. This rare mineral, found in meteorites and upper mantle rocks, is actually rarer than diamonds. However, the moissanite used in jewelry today is typically lab-created, offering a stunning alternative to diamonds. Lab-grown moissanite is made from silicon carbide (SiC), a structure created under intense pressure and heat over two to three months.

Moissanite’s brilliance and durability have made it a popular choice for those seeking a high-quality, ethical alternative to diamonds. Its unique optical properties, including a higher refractive index and greater light dispersion (fire), make it one of the most brilliant gemstones available.

2. What Is a Simulated Diamond?

Understanding Simulated Diamonds

Simulated diamonds are stones designed to mimic the appearance of diamonds, but they differ significantly in their physical, chemical, and optical properties. Unlike synthetic or lab-grown diamonds, which have the same properties as natural diamonds, simulants are made from entirely different substances.

Simulated diamonds, like those offered by IceTreasure, are often chosen for their affordability, eco-friendliness, and versatility. They are ideal for fashion jewelry or temporary trends, providing a glamorous look without the high cost of natural diamonds.

3. How Are Diamond Simulants Created?

Creation of Diamond Simulants

Various materials are used to create diamond simulants, each with its own production process:

Cubic Zirconia: A popular, budget-friendly diamond alternative made by melting powdered zirconium with zirconium dioxide. This mixture is cooled slowly to form crystals, which are then cut and faceted.
Gadolinium Gallium Garnet (GGG): Developed in the 1960s using the Czochralski method, GGG can be produced in various colors, including colorless "white."
Yttrium Aluminum Garnet (YAG): A synthetic material used to imitate diamonds, less commonly used today due to the availability of better alternatives like moissanite.
Strontium Titanate: Known for its extraordinary brilliance, this synthetic simulant was introduced in the 1950s and once marketed under names like Diagem and Fabulit.
Synthetic Spinel: A man-made version of natural spinel, offering a colorful and affordable option for simulated diamonds, often used in class rings and birthstone jewelry.
Glass and Plastic: These materials are some of the oldest and most widely used diamond simulants. Glass can mimic a variety of gemstones, while plastic is a versatile, inexpensive option often used in fashion jewelry.

4. Key Differences Between Moissanite and Simulated Diamonds

1. Sparkle

Sparkle, characterized by flashes of white and spectral-colored light, is a hallmark of diamonds. While many diamond simulants lack the sparkle of a real diamond, moissanite stands out with its exceptional brilliance and fire. Its sparkle is often compared to that of a diamond, making it a unique choice for those seeking an alternative.

2. Refractive Index

The refractive index measures how light bends as it passes through a stone, contributing to its fire. Moissanite has a refractive index of 2.65 to 2.69, which is higher than that of diamonds (2.417), making it one of the most brilliant gemstones available.

3. Light Dispersion (Fire)

Moissanite’s dispersion is approximately 0.104, significantly higher than diamond’s dispersion of 0.044. This means that under certain lighting conditions, moissanite can display more rainbow-like flashes of color compared to a diamond, adding to its unique appeal.

4. Thermal Conductivity

Both diamonds and moissanite exhibit high thermal conductivity, making them cool to the touch and difficult to distinguish with a simple thermal conductivity test. In contrast, most simulated diamonds, like cubic zirconia or glass, have much lower thermal conductivity and warm quickly when held.

5. Durability

Durability is measured using the Mohs Hardness Scale, which ranges from 1 to 10. Moissanite scores a 9.25, just below diamond, making it highly resistant to scratching and ideal for long-term wear. Other simulants, like synthetic spinel and cubic zirconia, are less durable, with lower hardness ratings.

6. Wear and Tear

Different stones exhibit varying levels of durability. Glass and plastic, for example, can easily show signs of wear and tear. Strontium Titanate and synthetic spinel may also lose their sparkle over time. In contrast, moissanite is highly durable, making it a suitable choice for everyday wear and a popular alternative to less durable simulants.

7. Environmental Impact

When comparing the environmental impact of simulated diamonds and moissanite, it’s important to consider the production processes. Lab-created moissanite, like those offered by IceTreasure, generally has a lower environmental footprint compared to mined diamonds. The process of creating moissanite in a lab requires fewer resources and causes less environmental disruption.

8. Ethical Considerations

Moissanite, being lab-created, is considered a conflict-free stone, free from the ethical issues that sometimes accompany diamond mining. On the other hand, simulated diamonds like cubic zirconia or synthetic spinel also avoid these ethical concerns, but they may not carry the same prestige or durability as moissanite.

9. Color & Clarity

Moissanite is graded using the 4Cs, similar to diamonds. It can also be produced in a variety of colors, offering options for those who desire something different. While some simulants like cubic zirconia are available in various colors, others may contain inclusions that reveal their synthetic origins.

10. Pricing

Moissanite is an affordable yet high-quality alternative to diamonds, often costing about one-tenth the price of a mined diamond of similar size and quality. This makes it an attractive option for those seeking a beautiful, budget-friendly stone.

5. So, Which Is Better: Moissanite or Simulated Diamond?

Choosing Between Moissanite and Simulated Diamonds

When it comes to deciding between moissanite and a simulated diamond, it largely depends on your needs and preferences. Simulated diamonds like those from IceTreasure are perfect for fashion jewelry and other temporary trends. On the other hand, moissanite is ideal for those looking for a durable, high-quality stone that offers the brilliance and fire of a diamond.

Who Should Choose Moissanite?

Moissanite is the perfect choice for those investing in fine jewelry or looking for a long-lasting, brilliant alternative to diamonds. Its availability and variety make it easy to create custom pieces or select from pre-made designs. Moissanite offers the sparkle, durability, and timeless beauty that makes it a top choice for engagement rings and other significant jewelry pieces.

Who Should Choose a Simulated Diamond?

Simulated diamonds, such as the Sona simulated diamond, are excellent for those seeking affordable, fashionable jewelry. While these stones offer a glamorous look, they do not replace the quality and durability of moissanite.

6. Frequently Asked Questions

1. Where Can I Buy Moissanite Rings?

Moissanite is widely available, with numerous online platforms offering custom creation or pre-made options. Its brilliance and durability make it a popular choice for fine jewelry set in premium materials like gold, platinum, or silver.

2. How Hard Is Moissanite?

Moissanite is exceptionally hard, with a Mohs rating of 9.25, making it nearly as durable as a diamond.

3. Does Moissanite Pass a Diamond Tester?

Yes, moissanite can pass a diamond tester that measures thermal conductivity, making it difficult to distinguish from a diamond in some cases.

7. Final Thoughts

When comparing moissanite to simulated diamonds, options like cubic zirconia, glass, and synthetic spinel are perfect for fashion jewelry. However, if you're seeking a high-quality, long-lasting alternative to diamonds, moissanite is the superior choice. IceTreasure offers a range of options, but moissanite stands out for its brilliance, durability, and affordability, making it a top pick for fine jewelry.

Janar Kirn

Janar Kirn, from Tallinn, Estonia, is a distinguished entrepreneur and a co-founder of Ice Treasure. With a career spanning since 2017, Janar has made significant strides in the jewelry industry, founding his first brand from the ground up.

Over the years, he has amassed extensive knowledge in the field, becoming a respected educator and jewelry specialist in Scandinavia. Known for his deep passion and expertise, Janar is dedicated to sharing his insights and experiences with others through this platform.

Share or comment!

Share this article

Comment

Experience the quality of ICE TREASURE, where our custom and stock jewelry, including chains, bracelets, grillz, watches, rings, earrings, pendants, and glasses, all embody superior craftsmanship and quality, passing the diamond test to ensure your satisfaction.

Quick links

Company

Account